Getty Images

Coming in at No. 9: A silvery, smoky eye

Here's how guys ranked this look on a scale of 1 to 10
Sexiness: 3
How likely they are to talk to her/ask her out: 3

Here's what they had to say:
The good: "She's fun and experimental, and doesn't take herself too seriously."

The bad: "She looks a little crazy." "If your makeup job makes a gorgeous woman look like this, that's very bad." "Too scary and non-approachable, you can't even try to look into her eyes."

The just plain weird: "She looks like a cyborg from a dystopian future." "If you want to look like a crack head ... you are doing a great job."