Getty Images

No. 8: A super dark and smoky eye

Here's how guys ranked this look on a scale of 1 to 10
Sexiness: 4
How likely they are to talk to her/ask her out: 3

Here's what they had to say:
The good (kind of): "This one is pretty nice, but I'm sure she'd try to kill you after you sleep with her." "Hot, but slightly terrifying."

The bad: "Yuck. She looks like a raccoon-eyed ghost. 'Nuff said." "How do I ask someone out if I can't even find the eyeballs in the sea of ink beneath her eyebrows?"

The just plain weird: "She's clearly a vampire, so as such, it seems like a bad idea to approach her." "Heroin Chic went out with the '90s, darling."