Getty Images

No. 3: False lashes

Here's how guys ranked this look on a scale of 1 to 10
Sexiness: 6
How likely they are to talk to her/ask her out: 6

Here's what they had to say:
The good: "I like that pinkish eye shadow." "Good basic makeup. Diva-ish." "Tasteful, subtle, not over done to the point that it's intimidating."

The bad: "Fake eyelashes. Bleech."

The just plain weird: "It looks like her eyes are leaking upwards."