If you thought you were past your “rebellious phase,” this fall’s grunge-inspired smoky eye may have you thinking otherwise. “Punk is back this fall, but has evolved into a grungier take on the look with heavily lined lids, messily smudged a little for that ‘I don’t really care’ feel,” says Amy Nadine, celebrity makeup artist with CoverGirl. The MAC Cosmetics makeup team says: “Liner and shadow have dropped any sense of sexy smokiness and picked up a rebellious streak that is unconventional, anti-glamour, and attitude-driven.”

If applying eyeliner isn’t your forte, it’s OK: the messier this look is, the better. Nadine suggests lining your top and bottom lashlines with black liner, then smearing the line with your finger to really nail it.