Apply a warm-toned, bronze-ish shimmer shadow along your upper and lower lashlines, across your lids and just above your creases. Try Shiseido Hydro-Powder Eye Shadow in Tiger Eye, $25. Don’t feel like purchasing a new shadow? No prob. Duprey says you can probably make due with what you’ve got at home. Just dust your lids with a matte brown shadow, then brush a warm brown shimmer shadow over top.