No one’s bangs caused as much controversy as Jessica Biel’s. When Biel emerged with her thick fringe in January, the Internet almost exploded with the amount of commentary flying back and forth. Some proclaimed the new style perfect for the star, while others labeled it “fugly.” But what do the experts say?

“I prefer Jessica without bangs because it opens up her face more. The thicker bangs seem too heavy for her face, but I’m not going to say she doesn’t pull it off. After all, she looked great in those wedding photos,” says Knudsen. If Biel wants to keep the bangs, Knudsen suggests going for a shorter style, not the eye grazers that she currently has.