What Real Girls Buy at Sephora

Benefit BadGal Lash Mascara

Paint it black

What she bought: Benefit BadGal Lash Mascara, $19

The reason she was there: “It’s the one I use normally and I just ran out of it. We came here specifically for Sephora, and [my boyfriend] didn’t have a choice!” says Louisa D. His reply? “She’s making it a miserable day.” (Joking, of course.)