Drop-dead gorgeous Jennifer Connelly makes us want to trade DNA, but sometimes she misses the mark in the makeup department. (Eh, the price of perfection …) Here, her cranberry shadow might make her green eyes pop, but it also matches her lipstick and her dress (too much?) and makes it look like she’s having an allergic reaction. We like her much better with a flattering gray shadow, see?

Next: What else not to do