What to use: A deep plum or navy shade of liner, a soft taupe shadow, and bronzer (no, really) can help make your eyes look more proportionate and close together.

How to use it: Line the inside corner of your eye with a deep shade of liner, and smudge a lighter shade of shadow around the corner for more definition, Stern says. Tap some bronzer on the bridge of your nose to create more depth and bring your eyes in on your face.

What NOT to do: Use really light colors in the inner corners of your eyes, Thomas says. Or else your eyes could look like they’re sitting on top of your ears. Yikes.