Heather: Dress: 0, Top: XS, Jeans: 0 short

Breanne: Dress: 2, Top: S, Jeans: 4

Elie: Dress: 6, Top: XS, Jeans: 6 long

Catie: Dress: 10, Top: L, Jeans: 14 short

Call it a fluke but at American Eagle Elie actually wore a smaller top than Breanne (the only time this happened). Catie also wore some of her smallest sizes of the day in this store.