The Gossip’s lead singer Beth Ditto seems to have a brow disappearance problem, which isn’t doing her any beauty favors. (Padilla calls these “Mona Lisa eyebrows.”) Instead, Ditto should aim for “a fuller, defined pair of brows,” says Padilla. As for the actual shape of the brows, Padilla recommends ones with a gentle arch. This will help “lift and balance out the roundness of her face,” he says.

While Ditto waits for her brows to grow in, which take about six to eight months, she can use brow makeup in the meantime. If the brows don’t grow back, there are other options out there, including eyebrow tattoos. However, Padilla says to look for a shop that uses a vegetable-based semi-permanent dye, which lasts about two years. This way, when the brow style changes, you (and Ditto) can change right along with it.