Amy Adams’ strawberry-blonde hair is one of the lighter shades of red. Your safest bet when it comes to playing with color “is to keep it sheer,” Stern says. Use soft eye shadow colors like apricot and peach to create a warm complexion, and top it off with brown mascara.

For your lips, go with a pretty stain (try CoverGirl Outlast Lipstain in Sassy Mauve, $7). Keep them looking “vibrant yet subtle,” Stern says.