Jewelry boutique (and tween girl haven) Claire’s had the best selection of friendship necklaces in the ’90s, but the most popular was the broken heart meant to be shared between two besties.

Confession:

“Those best friend charms where you’d have one half and your BFF had the other caused so many fights in elementary school. But when you had one, it made you feel like you had this special little pact. So thrilling in fifth grade.” — Meghan R.