Pelusi prefers Ashlee Simpson as a blonde because “this color works well naturally with her skin tone,” he says. It’s pretty, but we think the light color washes her out a bit. In our opinion, she looks even better as a “bronde” (you’ll see why on the next slide).

Our humble opinion: “She definitely looks like the little sister with this color. It’s pretty but looks too ‘Jess Simpson.'” — Molly Roemer, Associate Editor

Next: Ashlee Simpson as a brunette