This is our personal favorite color on Simpson. The light golden color of her hair matches her skin tone, and it’s “suited well for her with no effort,” Pelusi says. The dark blonde highlights are so warm and inviting. We can’t speak for her personality, but judging by her hair, we like her.

Our humble opinion: “The highlights might be a tad too chunky, but this light brown shade looks gorgeous with her skin tone.” — Sarah, Senior Associate Editor

Next: Ashlee Simpson as a redhead