As with her red hair, “the black only works because of her clothing choices,” says Pelusi. In this picture, “the black in the clothes sets well with the hair.” We think it kind of makes her fade into the background, though. Ugh, and our eyes keep being drawn back to the picture of her with that gorgeous brunette hair.

Our humble opinion:“It makes her look goth, and it doesn’t do anything for her.” — Molly Roemer, Associate Editor