Katharine McPhee’s ashy blonde hair doesn’t quiiite do it for us. The singer has sexy, smoldering eyes that are begging to be matched with the same dark hair color. “I don’t love the blonde,” says Pelusi. “It doesn’t seem natural on her skin tone.” Not to mention her darker eyebrows give her natural color away.

Our humble opinion: “It’s sophisticated and chic, and goes well with her skin tone. The cut is the best, too.” — Susan, Associate Editor

Next: Katharine McPhee as a light brunette