Since McPhee is a natural brunette, the dark hair “works so beautifully” against her skin, says Pelusi. It’s the perfect color for a young, breakthrough artist (and not-so-successful actress). Oh well, we loved her as a brunette on American Idol, and we love her still.

Our humble opinion: “Love it. It looks natural and totally stands out among all the blondes in Hollywood.” — Sarah, Senior Associate Editor