Oh, JTT. Who wouldn’t fall for his adorable smile and mussed-up hair? Thomas was one of the biggest teen heartthrobs of the ’90s, and it’s obvious why. As the goofy and mischievous middle child on the hit TV show “Home Improvement,” he got tons of attention from the girls (both on and off the screen).

An obsessed fan shares: “When I was around 12 years old, I became so in love with Jonathan Taylor Thomas after watching ‘Home Improvement.’ I wrote him a letter and got a letter back with his picture. I was soooo happy thinking he actually wrote it. I put it under my pillow and would make sure it was there almost every night. I even agreed to a $20 bet with my sister that I was going to marry him! The bet is still on.” — Jen A.