Out of the following four shades, “my favorite on Lindsay Lohan is the red,” Pelusi says. “It seems to blend beautifully with her skin tone.” We also love how it warms up her makeup and stands out against her dark shirt. It’s been a while since we’ve said this but … she looks very natural and pretty (well it was the color she was born with).

Our humble opinion: “It’s almost too red, it looks fake.” — Molly, Associate Editor

Next: LiLo as a brunette